Arbitration and ADR
The role of arbitral institutions in the New World Order
ICC Court President Claudia Salomon explores the importance of arbitral institutions and the rule of law in an uncertain world.

Claudia Salomon
President, ICC International Court of Arbitration
The phrase New World Order often describes a fundamental political or economic shift – one that triggers seismic change and forces societies and institutions to adapt to new circumstances. President Woodrow Wilson popularised the phrase to describe his post-World War I vision: the League of Nations and an era of peace and prosperity.
It didn’t turn out that way. The “war to end all wars” was followed by World War II. Then came the Cold War and shifts in global power balances. Today we find ourselves living in an increasingly multipolar world characterised by armed conflicts, competing regulatory systems, trade barriers, and declining confidence in international organisations and alliances. At the same time, we are grappling with the transformative power of artificial intelligence and other technologies that will reshape societies in ways we cannot even imagine.
Throughout these periods of upheaval, the ICC International Court of Arbitration has provided stability and a framework for resolving disputes. Since its founding in 1923 by entrepreneurs calling themselves the Merchants of Peace, the ICC Court has maintained its status as an independent, impartial, and trustworthy mechanism for resolving disputes and promoting cross-border trade, investment and commerce.
Arbitration in uncertain times
The ICC Court’s role is more important than ever in today’s fractured and dangerous world. Some studies have found that increases in bilateral trade interdependence and global trade openness can significantly reduce the likelihood of military conflicts. I would be naïve to suggest that free trade alone can prevent war, but I firmly believe that it might help deter an armed conflict that is both costly and pointless for all involved, particularly in cases involving valuable natural resources.
The ICC Court plays a pivotal role in this regard by offering its dispute resolution services to private entities, states and state-owned enterprises (SOEs) from around the world. While most parties involved in ICC arbitrations are typically private businesses or individuals, one-quarter of all cases in recent years involved states and/or SOEs.
Moreover, the ICC Court offers a proven mechanism for resolving disputes between states themselves. While purely state-to-state cases are rarely seen at the ICC Court, there are a significant number of ICC arbitrations where states are in dispute with SOEs or SOEs against one another. In other words, states are engaging in cross-border trade through their SOEs and choosing ICC Arbitration when disputes arise.
Recent examples include a dispute over an oil pipeline and a possible arbitration of a copper mining project.
Safeguarding the process of arbitration
The ICC Court is not only an independent and impartial forum for resolving disputes; it also safeguards the integrity of the entire process, for example, by preventing any party from derailing the proceedings.
The ICC Court fulfils the role of guardian of the arbitral process in multiple ways.
Appointing arbitrators
One is its role to appoint arbitrators if the parties do not nominate them, and to guarantee the independence and impartiality of the arbitrators through the appointment, challenge, and removal process. We take this responsibility very seriously, particularly regarding standards and transparency surrounding challenges and decisions. The Court Members, who bring different legal and cultural perspectives, thoroughly analyse these issues, grounded in the Court’s precedent on similar issues to maintain consistency. The reasons supporting these decisions are also provided if requested before the decision is made.
Avoiding unequal treatment or unfairness
What happens if an arbitration agreement grants one party the right to nominate the sole arbitrator or the presiding arbitrator? Or the arbitration agreement requires multiple claimants or respondents with conflicting interests to jointly nominate an arbitrator?
Article 13(10) of the 2026 ICC Rules provides that the ICC Court may appoint each member of the arbitral tribunal when the method of constitution in the arbitration agreement may pose a risk to the validity of the award.
This provision is in line with the well-known decision in Siemens v Dutco by the French Cour de Cassation and provides for additional safeguards for parties’ equality in the constitution of the arbitral tribunal – to avoid the risk of unequal treatment or unfairness which may in turn impact the validity of the arbitral award.
At the time of its adoption in 2021, it was expected that the ICC Court would only exercise the power in exceptional circumstances – and that indeed has been the case. Many of those who oppose this approach reject the role of arbitral institutions as guardians – and consider that such issues are better resolved in the enforcement stage. I beg to differ.
Non-participation of parties
Another issue is when parties decide not to participate. Early in my time at the Court, I was surprised to encounter cases in which a respondent declined to participate or, having initially participated, subsequently failed to appear later in the process. In recent years, nearly one in six cases (about 17%) involved non-participating parties; this rises to between 25% and 35% in cases under the Expedited Procedure Provisions, which primarily involve lower-value disputes.
The ICC Rules address non-participating parties in four specific ways: (i) by appointing an arbitrator if a respondent fails to appoint one; (ii) if a respondent does not submit an Answer, the arbitration will proceed and any question of jurisdiction will be decided by the arbitral tribunal directly, unless the Secretary General refers the matter to the Court which must be prima facie satisfied that the arbitration may indeed proceed; (iii) if any party refuses or fails to take part in the arbitration or any stage thereof, the arbitration will proceed notwithstanding such refusal or failure; and (iv) for any hearings, if any party is “duly summoned” but fails to appear without a valid excuse, the arbitral tribunal has the power to proceed with the hearing.
Monitoring of the process
In ICC Arbitration, the Secretariat safeguards the integrity of the arbitral process by monitoring the proceedings to protect due process and promote procedural efficiency. Although many institutions indicate that they exercise some degree of oversight over arbitral proceedings, the extent of this oversight varies considerably.
Quality check on awards
In an ICC arbitration, the Court’s scrutiny of the draft award is a unique and essential feature of the procedure. As stated in Article 37(3) of the ICC Rules, when the Court scrutinises draft awards, it considers to the extent practicable, the validity and enforceability of the award and the requirements of mandatory law at the place of arbitration. No award – whether partial or final or awarded by consent – may be rendered by an arbitral tribunal without first being scrutinised and approved by the ICC Court. Most draft awards are approved with comment but about 10% of the draft awards are not approved and then the Court will review a new draft after the arbitral tribunal considers the Court’s comments. If those draft arbitral awards with serious flaws had been issued under another arbitral institution’s rules and thus had not undergone the scrutiny process, the losing party may have no other recourse than to apply to vacate the award – thereby undermining the main reason the parties opted for arbitration in the first place: to receive an enforceable award.
Building trust in arbitral institutions
A key element of the rule of law is access to justice. At a time of growing instability, when conflicts and trade wars undermine this fundamental principle, arbitration under the auspices of an institution such as the ICC Court allows parties from different countries, legal systems and traditions, to resolve disputes and obtain a binding legal outcome. By applying a clearly defined set of rules, regulations and procedures, the Court helps uphold the rule of law, access to justice and the fair conduct of global commerce.
Guarding this process is even more critical as we navigate a New World Order, wherein parties are seeking every advantage and using their bargaining power in contract negotiations.
For all of us who care deeply about the integrity of arbitration and preserving the rule of law, as my colleagues and I do at the ICC Court, it is imperative that we continue to work together to strengthen trust in arbitral institutions so that economies can grow, commerce can thrive and nations achieve peace and prosperity.
