26Mar 19

The Role of the Judiciary in Arbitration

Mexico City, Mexico, • Spanish and English with simultaneous translation

The ICC International Court of Arbitration, The International Council for Commercial Arbitration (ICCA), and ICC Mexico are organizing a Congress to discuss the enforcement of local legal systems to ensure the efficiency of international arbitration decisions.


This event will include debates on the enforcement of court or arbitrator-ordered interim measures, judicial assistance in the taking and disclosure of evidence, annulment under public policy grounds, among others.

It will include the participation of representatives of the ICC Court and ICCA, and will feature world-class arbitration practitioners.

This conference will be followed by a co-organized (ICC YAF & Young ICCA) event on “Technology in Arbitration.

Who should attend?

Practicing lawyers, corporate counsel, in-house counsel, arbitrators and other dispute resolution services practitioners, academics and professionals involved and/or interested in obtaining further knowledge and keeping up to date with domestic and international arbitration in the Americas.


7:30 – 9:00Registration
Breakfast session
08:00 – 09:00Breakfast session organized by the Commission on Arbitration & ADR of ICC Mexico featuring the work of ICCA’s Task Force on Damages in International Arbitration.
Congress program
09:15 – 09:30Welcome and opening remarks
09:30 – 10:00Keynote address

Introduction on the shared spheres of jurisdiction between arbitral tribunals and national courts and the importance of a pro-enforcement legal regime to ensure the efficiency and success of the arbitral international proceedings.

10:00 – 11:00Panel on “Jurisdiction: the role of arbitral tribunals and courts”

Approaches under different legal systems on allocation of jurisdictional competence between arbitral tribunals and national courts. Authority of an arbitral tribunal to consider and decide disputes over its own jurisdiction, existence, validity, legality and scope of the parties’ arbitration agreement.

11:00 – 11:30Coffee break
11:30 – 12:45Panel on “Enforcement of court or arbitrator-ordered interim measures”

Enforceability of interim measures through national courts in different jurisdictions and tools that the arbitral tribunal has within its powers to ensure enforceability of interim measures (i.e. draw adverse inferences from the parties’ conduct).

12:45 – 14:00Panel on “Judicial assistance in the taking and disclosure of evidence”

Arbitrators generally enforce disclosure orders by seeking assistance of national courts, particularly when the orders are directed to third parties. Experience on requesting judicial assistance in the taking and disclosing evidence in different jurisdictions.

14:00 – 15:45Lunch speech

Advantages and drawbacks of the judiciary intervention or assistance in Latin America. Principal tensions between arbitral tribunals and national courts

15:45 – 17:00Panel on “Annulment under public policy grounds”

Interpretations in distinct jurisdictions of the concept of public policy as well as the standards used to prove its violation in order to avoid the enforcement of an arbitral award. Strategies used by counsel to minimize the risk of annulment under grounds of public policy by national courts. Grounds for refusal of enforcement in Article V of the New York Convention

17:00 – 17:15Coffee break
17:15 – 18:30Panel on “National Court’s discretion to enforce an award that has been annulled in its primary jurisdiction”

Article V(1)(e) of the New York Convention has been interpreted as granting discretion to National Courts for enforcing awards that were annulled in the seat of arbitration. It seems to be two different approaches, either to recognize the finality of the award or either the international comity in recognizing the judgment of a court in a primary jurisdiction. Are there other grounds for refusal of enforcement that might be equally or perhaps even more interesting for discussion, such as issues around arbitrability?

18:30 – 18:45Conclusions and closing remarks
19:00Cocktail reception


Juan Fernández ArmestoArmesto y Asociados (Madrid)
Cecilia Azar ManzurMember of the ICC International Court of Arbitration in representation of Mexico; ; Vice-President of the Commission on Arbitration & ADR of ICC Mexico;  Galicia Abogados, S.C. (Mexico City)
Doak BishopKing & Spalding (Houston)
Cavinder BullDrew & Napier (Singapore)
Bernardo M. CremadesB. Cremades y Asociados (Madrid)
Donald Francis DonovanDebevoise & Plimpton (New York)
María Fernanda Garza MerodioPresident of ICC Mexico; Orestia, S.A. (Mexico City)
Omar Guerrero RodríguezHogan Lovells (Mexico City)
Dominique HascherCo-Chair of ICCA’s Judiciary Committee; Supreme Judicial Court of France (Paris)
Albert Jan van den BergHanotiau & van den Berg (Brussels)
Andrés JanaBofill Mir & Alvarez Jana Abogados (Santiago de Chile)
Jean E. KalickiKalicki Arbitration (New York / Washington D.C.)
Gabrielle Kaufmann-KohlerPresident of International Council for Commercial Arbitration; Lévy Kaufmann-Kohler (Geneva)
Carolyn LammWhite & Case (Washington D.C.)
Carlos Loperena RuízMember of the ICC International Court of Arbitration in representation of Mexico; Loperena, Lerch y Martín del Campo, S.C. (Mexico City)
Neófito López RamosMagistrate of the Fifteenth Collegiate Court on Civil Matters of First District, Mexico City
Margarita Luna RamosRetired Justice of the Mexican Supreme Court of Justice (Mexico City)
Alexis MourrePresident of the ICC International Court of Arbitration (Paris)
Alejandro Ogarrio Ramírez EspañaPresident of the Commission on Arbitration & ADR of ICC Mexico; Ogarrio Daguerre, S.C. (Mexico City)
Guillermo Ortiz MayagoitiaFormer Chief Justice of the Mexican Supreme Court of Justice ; Von Wobeser y Sierra (Mexico City)
Lucy ReedDirector for the Centre for International Law at the National University of Singapore (Singapore)
Víctor Ruíz BarbosaVice-President of the Commission on Arbitration & ADR of ICC Mexico; Ruíz-Silva Abogados, S.C. (Mexico City)
Bernardo SepúlvedaCreel García-Cuéllar Aiza y Enríquez (Mexico City)
Eduardo Siqueiros TwomeySiqueiros Arbitration (Mexico City)
Claus von WobeserVice-President of ICC Mexico; Von Wobeser y Sierra S.C. (Mexico City)

Logistical notes


Four Seasons Hotel

Gran Salón, Paseo de la Reforma 500

Mexico City, Mexico.


For more information and registration please enter here.

  • Katherine Lievano
  • +507 385 7420
  • Project Officer

The International Chamber of Commerce is preparing for the publication of Incoterms® 2020, an update of the renowned regulations that define the responsibilities of buyers and sellers operating in the international trade system.

Sign up to our news alerts today to receive the latest news and information about the Incoterms® rules.